catlarks | Nonconathon 2022: Dear Author Letter

Hello, mystery creator!

Thank you for writing for me! (And, potentially, for being patient while I finalized this letter, haha.) Nonconathon is one of my all-time favorite exchanges and, no matter which fandom or pairing we matched on, I am very excited to see what you choose to create from my requests.

General Information

This is my noncon-specific but also generally-applicable list of likes and dislikes; if you're curious about my tastes in more consensual stories, feel free to peruse my past letters for other exchanges. It's not exhaustive, but is a pretty good cheat sheet for things that I love the most.

DISLIKES:

-first or second person POV
-happy endings or rape recovery focus
-victim turning tables on their attacker
-victim or loved ones taking revenge on the rapist
-straightforward brute force rape with no complicating elements
-rape motivated by race, sexuality, or disability of the victim
-rape of a trans person BECAUSE they are trans
-realistic hospital settings (medical procedures in other settings are A-OK)
-scat (all other bodily fluids in sexual situations are A-OK)
-major character death; background characters are fine but no death of characters listed in the ship
-extreme violence or gore beyond what can be (mostly) recovered from in universe
-amputation, specifically the depiction of or sexualization of limb removal

LIKES:

-both rapist and victim POV
-age gaps (both adult/minor and large age differences between adults)
-abuse of authority of all kinds
-power dynamics and power imbalances
-characters being overwhelmed and/or overstimulated
-manipulation, coercion, blackmail, or any other situation where the victim feels they cannot say "no"
-rape motivated by gender, age, class/wealth, or line of work
-body horror, transformation, and xeno/monster biology
-robogore, wound-fucking, and heavy pain kinks with a magic or mad science element involved
-emetophilia where the focus is on the experience of vomiting, not the product of "vomit"
-piss kink of all kinds (piss drinking, pissing inside, pissing on, someone pissing themselves, etc)
-trans, nonbinary, or genderless characters, and focus on gender identity/how gender plays into power dynamics
-gaslighting, mind control, and mental manipulation (preferably where the reader knows what's real)

Hopefully none of the things in these two lists seem contradictory to each other! Overall, I want maximum gross-dirty-nasty-wrong with no genuine comfort or rescue in sight, and I encourage anyone writing for me to follow their id and lean into the delicious fucked-up-ness as much as will please them. I love narratives that invite the reader to indulge and enjoy at the characters' expense, more than stories that are unremittingly bleak and hopeless in tone.

Re: Additional Tags: For each request, I have tried to put together a list of tags that will communicate the overall "vibe" I'm going for with the prompt. I don't expect or necessarily even want to see every single thing tagged used in one fic, but if you feel inspired to use as many of my tags as possible, feel free. Please do pick and choose in whatever way inspires you!

Re: Gender of Characters: I would prefer the characters in your story identify as the genders they were tagged as, so if the ship is queen/daughter, I'm not looking for king/daughter or queen/son, because the stated genders are (for me) part of the power dynamic that interested me. That said, I love trans characters and playing with gender, so I am open to characters tagged as male being written as trans men, or ones tagged as female being written as trans women, or either being written as nonbinary individuals.

For some prompts, I am more flexible on the genders of the participants and will note that within that section.

Table of Contents

For the letter-reader who wants to jump right to whichever section of my prompts is of greatest personal interest: I present to you, this highly specific table of contents.

I. General Information
II. Requests and Prompts
___1. Pokemon: Marnie & Piers
___2. Pokemon: Leon & Hop
___3. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Kira & Dukat
___4. Original Other/Multi: College Student & Professor
___5. Original M/F: Siblings & Catfishing
___6. Original M/F: Hands-On Sex Education
___7. Original F/M: Young Ladies & Their Handlers
___8. Original F/F: Mermaid & Aquarist
___9. Original F/F: Body Horror, Sleep Paralysis Demon Edition
___10. Original Other/Multi: Body Horror, Monster Doppelganger Edition
III. Final Words

Request One | Pokemon: Marnie & Piers

Ships:

-Marnie noncons Piers (Pokemon)
-Piers noncons Marnie (Pokemon)
-Sex Pollen makes Marnie noncon Piers (PKMN MVGS)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con, Underage

Additional Tags:

Fuck Or Die
Something Made Them Do It
Multiple Victims - Pining Characters Forced to Fuck
Inexperienced rapist
Intimacy - Touch-Starved Victim
Intimacy - Victim Treated Like Lover
Location - In Victim's Own Bed
Misunderstandings - Mistaken for Consent
Misunderstandings - Rapist Thinks Victim Wants It
Scenario - Gentle Rape
Penetration - Dick is Too Big
Sensation Play - Sensory Overload
Virginity - Loss of Virginity
Gaslighting - Victim Thinks They Asked For It
Wanted It but Not Like This - Victim(s) Wanted It
Aftermath - Aggressor attempts to comfort Victim

Prompts and Thoughts:

I picked all of the Piers & Marnie ships because what I am interested in with this pair is less about who the "aggressor" is, more about any scenario with mutually unrequited shameful feelings that are brought to the fore by some inciting incident or outside influence. That could be sex pollen, could be a pokemon whose abilities include hypnotic or soporific effects, could be perceived or real external pressure, from specific or imagined other individuals. I am open to a wide variety of possibilities!
I enjoy pokephilia, but for this prompt, I would prefer the focus be on Piers and Marnie having a sexual encounter with each other. So, "a pokemon made them do it" is welcome, but "a pokemon actively did sex things to one or both of them" is not what I'm looking for.
I tagged for potential underage; I see Marnie as being between 14-16 in-game and am happy to see her written at any age from 14 upwards, or with ambiguous/unstated age, or for this to happen at a future point where Marnie is over eighteen. Please choose whatever best suits your comfort and your id!
For Piers as the aggressor, I'd be up for Piers guiltily giving in to his long-repressed and shameful feelings for Marnie, while trying to be as kind and sweet and romantic about it as possible. I'd also be interested in the scenario where Piers may or may not have repressed feelings of his own, but because he believes Marnie wants it, he makes a sexual overture towards her. Mostly, what I'd love to see is Piers being uncomfortable and nervous and ashamed, despite being the one ostensibly guiding the encounter.
For Marnie as the aggressor, I will especially love any scenario where Piers feels like he should say no, but that, for whatever reason, he feels like he can't – be it because he doesn't want to hurt Marnie, or because some outside force won't let him, or because he himself wants it so much that he can't quite force himself to make her stop. Bonus points for the sex pollen scenario where Marnie is affected and Piers isn't, so even though Piers is the "victim," he feels shame and guilt over whether he's taking advantage, since Marnie isn't in her right mind.
Re: virginity, I looooove virginity kink and would love a virgin Marnie in any of these scenarios. Bonus for Piers not realizing she was a virgin until mid-coitus. I'd prefer a Piers who has sexual experience, but would be quite interested in a setup where Piers might have been wild in his youth or at least had some partners then, but where he hasn't been sexually active in a long time.
Re: intimacy: I'm interested in either or both of them being touch-starved and taking comfort in the more mundane intimacy happening on the edge of this fraught and complicated experience. I also looooove size difference, especially large insertions. I'd rather not see Marnie seriously pained by penetration but I'd love to see either or both of them struggling to make it work / make it so she feels good, especially juxtaposed with awkward attempts at comfort.

[top]

Request Two | Pokemon: Leon & Hop

Ships:

-Leon noncons Hop (Pokemon)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con, Underage

Additional Tags:

Abuse of Authority
Age Difference
Arousal - Rapist Makes Effort to Arouse Victim
Attitude - Victim Secretly Enjoys the Attention
Gaslighting - Victim Desperate to Please Person They Idolize
Gaslighting - Victim Thinks They Asked For It
Inexperience - Victim In Over Their Head
Intimacy - Touch-Starved Victim
Intimacy - Victim Treated Like Lover
Location - In Victim's Own Bed
Misunderstandings - Mistaken for Consent
Misunderstandings - Rapist Thinks Victim Wants It
Penetration - Dick is Too Big
Power Imbalance - Aggressor in Position of Power over Victim
Praise - Victim Wants Rapist’s Praise/Approval
Scenario - Gentle Rape
Size Difference - Small Victim/Large Aggressor
Virginity - Loss of Virginity
Something Made Them Do It

Prompts and Thoughts:

I tagged for underage; for this ship, I think I'd prefer Hop on the younger side, but am happy with ambiguous/unstated age, or with Hop being newly over eighteen. Please choose whatever best suits your comfort and your id!
One of my favorite potential scenarios here is the one where Leon isn't especially romantically or sexually interested in Hop, but Hop has been sooooo over the top about admiring Leon that Leon thinks Hop wants it. And, perhaps feeling guilty over how much Hop has struggled with his pokemon journey due to being in Leon's shadow, he decides that he has to give Hop this, at least just the one time. Basically: I would love to see Leon feeling awkward and horrible despite being the aggressor, and Hop either: also having a bad time because he really wasn't into his brother, or having a "wanted it, but not like this" bad time because he didn't ever want Leon to know and he can tell Leon is just humoring him.
For "something made them do it," the other setup I think would be really fun is any situation where external pressure makes Leon do it – sex pollen, a pokemon's influence, chairman Rose, some nefarious greyfaces, whatever feels most interesting. Leon is a bit of an idiot who gets one idea in his head and then barges forward without bothering to second-guess, so overall, I like any situation where Leon choosing to do something to Hop is the kind of bad decision he maybe could have avoided, if he'd only stopped long enough to think a little harder.
While it isn't what was nominated, if you are interested in the role reversal of "Hop noncons Leon," I would also love any scenario where Hop's idolization of Leon does cross over into romantic obsession and where he slowly escalates and pushes Leon's boundaries – Leon, who is kind of an idiot and just doesn't realize that it's increasingly sexual, very not brotherly behavior until he's in up to his neck – until Leon is backed into a corner he doesn't know how to get out of and feels like he just can't say no to his baby brother.
Other miscellaneous likes: leaning into Hop's idolization of Leon and this experience tarnishing it is great, size difference is amazing, especially re: penetration/large insertions, miscommunication and a mutually bad time that could have been mitigated by better communication is great, and actually exploring the fallout afterward would be delicious, if you are so inclined.

[top]

Request Three | Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Kira & Dukat

Ships:

-Kira Nerys noncons Dukat (STDS9)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con

Additional Tags:

Asphyxiation/Breathplay
Cock and Ball Torture
Humiliation
Anal Penetration as Act of Dominance
Sex Toys - Pegging
Penetration - Forced to Penetrate
Motive - Rape as Powerplay
Doppelganger - Raped by Evil(er) Version of Crush/Lover
Scenario - Dark Mirror/Clone Rapes Victim
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Scenario - Victim Made to Seem Like Aggressor
Wanted It but Not Like This - Victim(s) Wanted It
Xeno - Non-Human Genitalia

Prompts and Thoughts:

I would absolutely love mirrorverse Kira getting her hands on prime universe Dukat, thus the "raped by an evil version" and "dark mirror" tags. I'm fine with a handwavey explanation for why mirrorverse Kira and Dukat are in the same universe, but I'd be delighted by a plotty one/additional complications, if you are so inclined. If writing mirrorverse Kira, I'd love to see her having the time of her life being amazingly mean just for funsies, the sky is the limit.
For regular universe Kira, I would prefer a scenario that works with her resentment of Dukat and their fraught history re: the occupation. Something that may have initially been ill-advised but consenting, only to become much less so for Dukat as the scene continues and he realizes what sort of catharsis Kira wants out of it, might be good.
Regarding other characters, I like Odo/Quark and Garak/Bashir and would prefer not to see noncon of either of those, but am happy with background inclusion. I don't hate Odo/Kira but am pretty "meh" on it, so I'd rather not see it mentioned unless it's actually being used for Plot Reasons. Mention of other canon pairs is fine; mention of other non-canon pairs is not preferred but tolerable.
Re: sexual content, I'm really interested in the powerplay angle, pain kinks, and xeno for this pair. Anything playing with any of those elements will delight me! I don't have solid headcanons on cardassian anatomy, but if you have interesting ideas about how lizard alien sexual anatomy works, I would LOVE to hear about it. I also just really, really love very controlled choking kink and dick abuse, so do with that as you will.

[top]

Request Four | Original Other/Multi: College Student & Professor

Ships:

-College student noncons Professor who is already facing allegations of abuse (Any/Any)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con

Additional Tags:

Age Difference
Betrayal - Victim's Consent is Asked but Denial Ignored
Degradation
Substances - Date Rape Drugs/Roofies
Gaslighting - Manipulative Aggressor
Gaslighting - Pretending To Not Be In Control To Get Away With Rape
Humiliation - Verbal Humiliation
Intimacy - Forced Kissing
Motive - Rape to Demonstrate Victim’s Helplessness
Orgasm - Forced Orgasm
Power Imbalance - Victim in Position of Power over Aggressor
Public - Raped Surreptitiously
Scenario - Blackmailed/Coerced
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Scenario - Victim Made to Seem Like Aggressor

Prompts and Thoughts:

For the genders of the participants, I am requesting no male aggressor for a female professor, but any other gender combination will please me. I would prefer a male professor, just slightly, but what matters most to me is definitely the dynamic, so choose genders as you will.
I would prefer a professor who is 10+ years older than the student, but feel free to follow your heart for whatever level of age difference works best for the story you want to write!
For scenarios, my favorite angle is the one where the professor is under investigation for these preexisting allegations of (sexual) abuse and that is the reason why the student has targetted them, but where taking "revenge" on a "deserving" victim is still secondary to the student's selfish desires. Those "desires" might be a preexisting attraction to the professor; they might simply be a desire to be in control, to manipulate, and to punish.
For tone, the thing that will delight me the most is a really mean-spirited, clever, vengeful aggressor taking the opportunity to make their victim feel as helpless and miserable as possible. If you're so inclined, I would reeeeally love a very psychological, dialogue-focused take on this; I would love to see the verbal humiliation, the student explaining the blackmail scenario/explaining how the professor can't say no because everyone already believes they're a rapist so no one will believe them, and/or the student verbally, repeatedly asking for consent or permission and then ignoring any refusals or evidence that agreement was given only under duress.
For a few other miscellaneous thoughts: dosing the professor with roofies to further reinforce their powerlessness is great, forced kissing and the student just generally enjoying the professor's discomfort with their actions is great, and semi-public sex somewhere on campus, with a bit of "you have to be quiet, because if we're caught then you will just look like a rapist again" angle is great. Whether or not the professor is guilty of the things they've been accused of is up to you; I do love scenarios where bad people get what's coming to them, but I'm also fascinated by the scenario where the professor is innocent but the student doesn't care, because the situation is more about power than about punishing an actually guilty person.

[top]

Request Five | Original M/F: Siblings & Catfishing

Ships:

-Catfishing brother noncons sister chatting about noncon fantasy (m/f)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con, Underage

Additional Tags:

Roleplay - Rape Roleplay Turns into Rape
Scenario - Forced to Live Out Darkest Fantasy
Arousal - Rapist Forces Arousal in Victim
Bargaining - Victim Forced to Choose Which Hole Gets Raped
Betrayal - Rape by Deception
Betrayal - Rapist Encourages Boundary Setting in order to Cross Them
Crying
Dehumanization
Substances - Date Rape Drugs/Roofies
Gaslighting - Rapist Makes Victim Believe It Was Their Idea
Humiliation - Victim Forced to Pretend They Enjoy Rape
Identity Issues - Mistaken Identity
Intimacy - Forced Kissing
Location - In Victim's Own Bed
Nipple Torture
Obsession - Rapist In Love With Victim
Object Insertion
Penetration - Wrong Hole
Resistance - Rapist Aroused by Victim Fighting Back
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time

Prompts and Thoughts:

I would strongly prefer an older brother/younger sister setup for this prompt, but as far as exact ages go, am equally interested in them both being young adults, bro being college-aged (maybe not living at home while sis still does?) while sis is an older teen, or them both being older teens living at home. I would prefer the younger party to be 16 or older for this one, but I'm fine with unstated/ambiguous ages, so long as everyone is clearly post-pubescent.
I looooove identity porn and am very interested in the catfishing angle; does the brother present himself online as an idealized version of himself? As some other identity he would prefer to inhabit? Or maybe as whatever sort of person he imagines his sister would be most attracted to, since she's his target? I'd extra love the scenario where the brother was catfishing as a girl in order to get close to his bisexual sister, but am equally open to other angles!
I would love a setup where, after extensive online discussion of her fantasies and explicit planning re: boundaries, acts to be performed, safewords, etc, the sister arranges for her "online friend" / online significant other to "surprise" her at home and play out her rape fantasy. I'm really interested in that element of, making yourself vulnerable only to have something you thought you wanted twisted and used against you, and of blaming yourself for what happened to you because you invited it, didn't you? You explicitly asked for this, so don't you deserve it?
Re: the brother's attitude, my favorite angle is the love/obsession angle, with bonus points for the brother having conflated wanting to possess/please his sister with genuinely really wanting to hurt her. I am fascinated by that sort of line-blurring, and by the idea that he knows that what he's doing is wrong but is still somewhat lying to himself about how he's just, fulfilling his sister's secret fantasy. The fact that he deliberately goes against every boundary she set, or deliberately makes her perform acts she'd refused, is just him giving her a better, sexier, more realistic experience. Or it's sexier for him, at least!
Re: the acts performed, I am most interested in the boundary-crossing and choosing of acts the sister had refused, over having explicit preferences on what those acts are. That said, I am a big, big fan of basically all types of pain kinks (especially breast/nipple torture), bonus points for the very controlled inflicting of pain. I also really like the sister having requested only one kind of penetration (dealer's choice on whether she wanted vaginal or anal), only to have the other option forced on her, and am intrigued by the degradation possibilities of object insertion, be it an object the brother brought specifically intending to fuck her with it, or an opportunistic choice from the objects around them in the moment.
Basically: I would love most of all to see a brother with sooooo many unresolved issues re: his sister, his attraction to her, and his sexual desires in general, having that all come to a head and where he takes it out on sis in the most lovingly terrible, over-the-top way possible.

[top]

Request Six | Original M/F: Hands-On Sex Education

Ships:

-Sex ed teacher & male students noncon shy female student by using her as a class demo (M/F)

Major Tags: Underage

Additional Tags:

Abuse of Authority
Inexperience - Virginal Victim's Knowledge of Sex is Rudimentary or Metaphorical
Masturbation - Victim Forced to Masturbate
Motive - Rape as Instructional Demonstration
Motive - Rape to Teach a Lesson
Power Imbalance - Aggressor in Position of Power over Victim
Praise - Victim Wants Rapist’s Praise/Approval
Public - Raped Openly
Resistance - Cooperative Victim
Society - Rape as Part of Education
Spectators - Victim(s) Forced to Perform for Crowd/Audience
Virginity - Loss of Virginity

Prompts and Thoughts:

For this one, I only tagged underage, because I really want the either high school or middle school sex ed classroom setting. As long as the students are post-pubescent, I'm fine with their ages being anywhere from 12-18, or with ambiguous/unstated age. For the age of the teacher, I'd prefer him middle-aged but am really not picky; follow your id!
Setting-wise, I prefer an AU where hands-on sex ed is the norm in the story world, so the teacher and the male students aren't doing something wrong per se, they're just being particularly mean-spirited in picking on someone shy and uncomfortable to be the star of the demo. That said, if you strongly prefer the version where this is a dirty little secret and society would not turn a blind eye to the actions of the aggressors if they were found out, I will take that version, too!
For execution, I especially love the idea of the teacher directing the action, but the male students doing most or all of the dirty work. I love clinical dirty talk and especially love the idea of the teacher narrating how the acts are being performed or how they should be performed to the rest of the class, to make certain the lesson is instructive!
For the acts themselves, I'm very flexible on exactly what is done to the victim, but would strongly prefer that at least two or three different acts be "demoed" for the class. Bonus points for starting out with something "easy" only to continually push the victim farther and farther out of her comfort zone with escalating intensity of sex acts, extra bonus points for things like "demonstrating proper condom use by having one boy fuck her with a condom and one without" and/or "demonstrating different contraceptive methods; this boy will demonstrate the 'pull out' method but whoops, he got too enthusiastic and came prematurely!"
I fucking love virginity kink; I would adore a victim who has definitely never had sex before, maybe never even kissed anyone before, please do lean into the disparity of experience as much as will please you, because it will delight me.

[top]

Request Seven | Original F/M: Young Ladies & Their Handlers

Ships:

-Hormonal Young Lady noncons The Butler (F/M)
-Teenage Crown Princess noncons Royal Bodyguard (F/m)
-Teenage Daughter of Mob Boss noncons Handsome Young Mob Enforcer (F/m)

Major Tags: Underage

Additional Tags:

Age Difference
Attitude - Cheerful Rapist
Clothing - Clothed Sex
Escalation - "Innocent" Groping
Escalation - Initially Nonsexual Demands Gradually Become More Sexual
Intimacy - Forced Kissing
Intimacy - Forced to dance with rapist
Intimacy - Forced to flirt with rapist
Loyalty - Rapist Takes Advantage of Victim’s Loyalty
Loyalty - Submission To Rape as Part of Duty/Job
Magic - Rape Gives Rapist Influence Over Victim
Misunderstandings - Rapist Doesn’t Think It's Rape
Misunderstandings - Victim Thinks They Can't Say No
Non-Penetrative - Frottage
Non-Penetrative - Intercrural
Penetration - Forced to Penetrate
Power Imbalance - Aggressor in Position of Power over Victim
Resistance - Stoic Victim
Scenario - Rapist Having Thoroughly Self-Indulgent Good Time
Size Difference - Large Victim/Small Aggressor

Prompts and Thoughts:

This is the other request which I only tagged for underage. I'm imagining the girls in the 15-17 age range, but am fine with ambiguous/unstated ages so long as the character is clearly post-pubescent. For the men, I'd prefer them about a decade older than the girl, but not quite old enough to be her father. Anywhere in that middle ground will delight me!
Re: interpersonal dynamic, I'm looking for a privileged, entitled young lady newly coming into her own as a sexual being, vs the fully-adult man she latches onto as the object of her fledgling desires, and as a seemingly "safe" option to explore her sexuality with, due to his position as a protector or other servant whose literal job it is to serve her. I love the angle of the girl slowly escalating, as her comfort and experience grows, vs the man feeling like he can't say no and initially thinking that if he appeases her a little, she'll get bored and stop, only for her to speed up and leave him scrambling to slow her down.
Re: intimacy & duty, I would especially love any take on these ships that really plays into the formality involved in being a butler or a bodyguard and interacting with A Young Lady. I love the contrast between the code of behavior these men should be following, and the new script the young lady drags them into, especially with things like the forced flirting or forced dancing. I would extra love to see the man struggling to perform Highborn Formality (flirting like a gentleman would, leading a ballroom-style dance, etc) rather than Servant Formality. I also love loyalty kink, so anything leaning into that angle would be excellent!
Re: sex acts performed, I love non-pen and especially love the angle of "it's okay because it's not really sex, it's just a little rubbing, it's just a little flirting!" I love both characters making excuses and pretending everything is fine, until the man hits the point where his stoic facade starts to crack and he's forced to accept that it's not fine and he doesn't know how to stop things. And on the flipside, I love any setup where the girl is actively working toward getting a cock in her, bonus points for the man doing everything he can think of to avoid that only to ultimately fail, extra bonus points for him being terrified of accidentally getting her pregnant.

[top]

Request Eight | Original F/F: Mermaid & Aquarist

Ships:

-Captive Mermaid noncons Aquarist (F/F)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con

Additional Tags:

Attitude - Cheerful Rapist
Betrayal - Victim Would Have Consented If Asked
Body Horror
Breeding Instincts
Hypnotism
Intimacy - Rapist Plays with Victim’s Hair
Magic - Rapist Uses Magic to Overpower Victim
Magic Addicts Victim to Sex with Assailant
Mind Control - Mental Compulsion/Glamouring
Misunderstandings - Cultural Misunderstanding Leads to Rape
Monster - Failing to Tame the Beast
Monster Come has an Aphrodisiac Effect
Orgasm - Multiple Orgasms
Oviposition
Pregnancy - Used as an Incubator
Wanted It but Not Like This - Victim(s) Wanted It
Xeno
Xeno - Non-Human Genitalia

Prompts and Thoughts:

The thing that initially intrigued me with this ship was the logistics of how a captive mermaid might turn the tables on the aquarist. I'm imagining the aquarist as a hobbyist, rather than someone working at a public aquarium, but I'll happily read a story about either interpretation. With a hobbyist, there are so many interesting points raised: maintaining a home aquarium of that size must be a huge undertaking requiring serious dedication. And how does one acquire a mermaid for a home aquarium, anyway? How well informed is this aquarist about what she got herself into, really?
I would prefer a well-intentioned, benevolent (maybe-naive) aquarist, and am fine with one who was simply uninformed about the realities of how mermaids are acquired and offered to private owners. For the mermaid, I would prefer a character who isn't malicious; she's simply following her nature, whether or not that leads to bad results for the aquarist.
Re: xenobiology, I love love love xeno and would adore any story that really gets into the weird and potentially-horrifying reality of mermaid anatomy. I especially love mermaids that are beautiful on the surface but where that is a very thin veneer covering the horrific (needle-toothed?) reality. I would also love xeno as explanation for how a captive mermaid gets the better of her human keeper, be that via hypnotism, mental compulsion, benign exposure to ~mermaid fluids~ that compel the human to make herself available for sex, or some other option!
Re: breeding instincts, I know not everyone who loves xeno also loves breeding kink, but I love oviposition and breeding kink. While I will be delighted with a scenario where the mermaid just wants to fuck and doesn't comprehend silly human things like "consent," I would also adore the version where the entire situation is prompted by the mermaid's need to breed and where she's simply doing what she has to do to appease those urges. I love seeing humans stuffed (pleasurably, painfully) full of eggs, humans used as an incubator, the human then having to pass those eggs when it's time for them to hatch or the version where they hatch internally and it's a closer-to-live-birth "push out the new creatures" situation.
Re: cultural misunderstanding, I also love instincts and cultural habits surrounding breeding. I would adore seeing the mermaid's attempts at caretaking post-egging because the aquarist is now the "mother" of the mermaid's future babies, be that attempts at feeding, grooming (playing with her hair!), cuddling, or sex. I love scenarios where knocking someone up just compels the character doing the impregnating to have way, way, way more sex with the newly-pregnant one or, on the flipside, scenarios where being pregnant/full of eggs makes that character super horny and in need of relief. Orrrr, if monster come/mermaid fluids/magic have addicted the aquarist to sex with the mermaid, maybe she's just desperate for more sex in spite of being very, very full of eggs.

[top]

Request Nine | Original F/F: Body Horror, Sleep Paralysis Demon Edition

Ships:

-Sleep Paralysis Demon noncons Human She Was Assigned To (F/F)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con

Additional Tags:

Amnesia - Memory Alteration/Manipulation
Asphyxiation/Breathplay
Body Horror
Doppelganger - Raped by Someone/Something That Looks Like Their Lover But Isn’t
Emetophilia
Magic - Rape Gives Rapist Influence Over Victim
Magic - Shapeshifting Rapist Rapes Victim In More Than One Shape
Mind Reading Rapist Takes Advantage of Victim's Shameful Kinks
Mind/Body Control - Paralysis
Scenario - Victim initially hates it but begins to enjoy it during the act
Sensation Play - Sensory Overload
Shapeshifting Rapist's Cock Enlarges Inside Victim
Somnophilia - Victim Woken up by Sex
Supernatural - Invisible/Intangible Rapist
Telepathy - Dream Invasion
Telepathy - Psychic Rape/Mind Rape
Torture - Sensory Deprivation
Xeno
Xeno - Non-Human Genitalia
Xeno - Tentacles

Prompts and Thoughts:

This ship allows for sooooo many good body horror and mindfuck interpretations and I love all of them; the nature of a sleep paralysis demon as something associated with nightmares makes me think "shapeshifter," and I really love that there's a lot of room for interpretation and creativity in how the demon looks and how her body works.
Re: identity kink, one fun angle would be the demon-as-shapeshifter taking the form of someone the victim is dating, or other people from the victim's life. I both love the angle of "she feels comfortable and happy at first, fucking someone she loves and trusts, until it subtly twists and increasingly goes Bad and turns into a horror show" or, on the flipside, having the demon take the form of someone she hates or who makes her uncomfortable and fucking with her head about why she would have started having sex with them in the first place. I love the bait-and-switch and I love the setup where the victim has a series of encounters with the demon which increasingly force her to doubt and question what and who is real.
Re: Xenophilia, I also like the idea of the demon fucking her victim in different monstrous shapes. I love tentacles, I love exotic genitalia, I love large insertions; I love the demon being able to mindread/see the victim's dreams and using that information to alter her shape for maximum horror, or for the ideal blend of "things the victim finds sexy, plus things she finds deeply upsetting." I love sensory and mental overload, and the idea of the demon using her shapeshifting abilities to push the victim's limits on both counts.
Re: Somnophilia, I love somno in general and I love how well a sleep paralysis demon lends itself to somno. For this prompt, I really love the concept of blurring the lines between sleep and wakefulness; I love the idea that the demon can invade and shape the victim's dreams, so when she's fucked awake in the real world, she doesn't know whether she's still asleep or if she's woken up, or if it even matters, when her body is paralyzed and there's no way to escape the situation in either scenario.
Re: Paralysis, while I love the creeping, growing horror of a character being unable to move while something else is acting upon her unresponsive body against her will, what I find extra fun with the sleep paralysis demon angle is, the moment when the victim stops being paralyzed. I would love to see her having an especially strong physical response once her body is able to have a response, be it vomiting, or hyperventilating, or something else. I also love the thought of the demon only letting go of the paralysis once her victim is too aroused and caught up in the throes of what's happening to try to stop it.
Re: Memory Alteration, I'm less interested in amnesia and more interested in the demon altering the victim's memory through her dreams and forcing her to question reality as the experience goes on. I know writing multiple encounters is a big ask, so I'd also be interested in any scenarios that depict one encounter but imply that it's a long-standing pattern.

[top]

Request Ten | Original Other/Multi: Body Horror, Monster Doppelganger Edition

Ships:

-B&B Hostess Replaced By Monster Doppleganger noncons Amateur Detective Repeat Guest (Other/F)

Major Tags: Rape/Non-con

Additional Tags:

Aftermath - Rapist Seeks Forgiveness and Rapes Victim Again when Refused
Amnesia - Memory Alteration/Manipulation
Arousal - Rapist Aroused by Killing
Asphyxiation/Breathplay
Attitude - Rapist Sincerely Admires Victim
Betrayal - Victim Initially Consents But Rapist Won’t Stop
Blood and Bloodplay
Body Horror
Breeding - Impregnated by Monster
Comeplay - Addictive Come
Gaslighting - Manipulative Aggressor
Identity Issues - Mistaken Identity
Magic - Shapeshifting Rapist Rapes Victim In More Than One Shape
Mind Control - Mental Compulsion/Glamouring
Obsession - Rapist In Love With Victim
Shapeshifting Rapist's Cock Enlarges Inside Victim
Telepathy - Forced Bond
Telepathy - Mental Suggestions During Rape
Xeno - Non-Human Genitalia
Xeno - Tentacles

Prompts and Thoughts:

Re: the genders of the characters, when I nominated this ship to a previous exchange, I put it as any/any and was primarily envisioning a male or trans male amateur detective. I would prefer the hostess be (dfab) female-bodied originally, but what the doppelganger really is, is up for debate, and as far as I'm concerned, the detective can be any gender that suits your fancy.
My favorite scenario for this ship is one where the doppelganger, whatever it really is, encounters the amateur detective, becomes obsessed with them, and either steals the body of or otherwise replaces the hostess in order to get close to them. I prefer that the hostess and detective have a prior relationship, be it as amicable exes, friends, two people mutually pining and/or suffering through UST, or whatever best serves the story. What's important is: the amateur detective knows the hostess, and they're clever, and they should be uniquely qualified to identify an imposter… But maybe they don't put the pieces together in time.
Re: Xenophilia, I love the idea of the doppelganger first having sex with the detective in human form (probably consensually), then either mid-scene or in a later scene, their real identity is revealed and their shape changes. Whether they only have two forms, or can shapeshift beyond that, is up to you; either way, I love tentacles, large insertions, prehensile or otherwise moldable cock-or-cock-equivalent, and body horror in general.
Re: the "rapist aroused by killing" tag, I would prefer that apply to NPCs, if you're interested in a more muder-mystery angle, where the doppelganger has been killing other people in or around the B&B and where every time that happens, they get really horned up and want to fuck the detective. On a similar note, I would prefer that the other more "aggressive" tags, like asphyxiation and bloodplay, be more out of obsessive love than malice.
Re: telepathy and mind control, another angle I think could be really fun is one where it's just a fact of the doppelganger's species that either they can read minds by default, or can use sex to form a psychic bond that then allows them to read minds. I like the idea of their obsession with the detective pushing them to have this person in every way possible, mentally as well as sexually, where they want to get inside the detective's head and learn everything about them and use that knowledge to have even more consuming, overwhelming sex with them.

[top]

Final Words

That's everything from me! I know this is a massively long letter and I thank you deeply for making it all the way to the end. I love this exchange very much for being an unapologetic, enthusiastic place for like-minded creators to make all sorts of nasty, iddy content, and with that spirit in mind: I look forward to seeing what you have created for me!